Dom's Take · 5 min read

Why I Was Wrong About Purchase Price (And How to Win in a Normalizing Market)

Originally published November 16, 2026 · Dominic Kramer, NMLS #1946539

I used to think getting the lowest purchase price was the ultimate goal for home buyers. In a balanced market, structuring seller concessions to buy down your rate is a far more powerful strategy.

Dominic Kramer recording a mortgage market update in his podcast studio
Recording a Washington market update

When I first passed my mortgage exam, I believed the ultimate goal of any home purchase negotiation was simple. I thought a buyer won the deal by slashing the seller's list price as low as possible. It made sense on paper because a lower price meant a smaller loan, which felt like the most direct path to saving money.

But running thousands of consumer loans across different industries taught me a hard lesson about how money actually moves. In a balanced, normalizing housing market, focusing solely on the sales price is a major strategic error. If you want to see my raw thoughts on how financing structures outperform list price discounts, you can read my regular entries over on Dom's Take.

The Math of Seller Concessions

Let us look at how the math actually breaks down when you have room to negotiate. If you convince a seller to drop their price by $10,000, your monthly payment barely budges, often by less than $60 a month. However, if you keep the purchase price at the original level and ask the seller for a $10,000 credit to buy down your interest rate, the payment drop can be three to four times larger.

This shifts the entire negotiation away from a battle over the sticker price and toward a discussion about financing structure. You can use our mortgage payment calculator to compare these scenarios yourself by toggling the purchase price and entering different interest rates in the rate field to see how much more a temporary or permanent buydown saves you compared to a minor price cut. By using the seller's funds to pay down your interest rate or cover your closing costs, you keep more cash in your bank account while securing a sustainable monthly payment.

Local Realities in Shoreline

Applying this strategy requires understanding your local market. If you are shopping in Shoreline, Washington, you are dealing with a distinct mix of mid-century ramblers, split-levels, and rapidly popping up new construction townhomes. These properties come with King County property taxes that significantly impact your total monthly housing expense.

Because Shoreline sits just north of Seattle, the competition remains steady, but the market is no longer a frantic bidding war where buyers waive every contingency. Sellers of older homes with deferred maintenance are often highly motivated to offer concessions instead of executing expensive repairs themselves. If you expand your search to other parts of King County, you will find that these concessions can be structured to solve different financial bottlenecks, whether that means paying off your high-interest debt at closing or buying down your interest rate for the first few years.

Program Selection and Hidden Boundaries

Another piece of advice I have changed my mind about is assuming that standard conventional loans are always the default path for buyers with solid credit. Program selection is a massive lever. For example, some buyers look at outlying areas of the county and do not realize they might qualify for zero-down financing. While these do not apply to dense suburban areas like Shoreline, looking further east or north opens up possibilities like USDA rural home loans, which offer highly competitive rates and lower mortgage insurance costs than conventional financing.

  • Prioritize seller credits over price drops to maximize your monthly payment reduction.
  • Verify the property-specific tax rates in King County since tax assessments vary by neighborhood.
  • Examine different loan programs early rather than defaulting to a standard conventional 30-year fixed.
  • Keep your inspection contingency intact to identify repairs that can be converted into closing cost credits.
  • Review your total cash out of pocket alongside your monthly payment goals instead of looking at them in isolation.

Financial Literacy and System Dynamics

Understanding the whole system is what keeps you from overpaying. The federal government has recognized the importance of this knowledge, with the Consumer Financial Protection Bureau supporting the National Strategy for Financial Literacy [2] to help Americans build better saving and investing habits. In my view, mortgage literacy is the most critical part of that equation because a home is the largest financial transaction most people will ever make.

When you understand how lender margins, points, and credits interact, you stop viewing the mortgage as a rigid product and start viewing it as a customizable tool. A normalizing market is not something to fear; it is an environment where smart buyers who understand loan structures can outnegotiate buyers who only look at the sales price.

Questions I get about this

Sellers often care about their net proceeds and how the final sales price affects neighboring home valuations. A price drop lowers the recorded sales price of the home, which can hurt local comparables and make their neighborhood look like it is declining. Giving a seller concession allows them to keep the recorded sales price higher while giving you the exact same financial benefit at closing, making it a win-win for both parties.

Yes, but there are strict limits depending on your loan program and your down payment amount. For conventional loans on a primary residence, seller contributions are generally capped at 3% to 9% of the purchase price, depending on how much down payment you put forward. It is essential to calculate these caps before writing an offer so you do not negotiate for credit amounts that you are legally unable to use at the closing table.

Dom's take

I got a call last Tuesday from a client who was ready to walk away from a beautiful split-level in Shoreline because the seller refused to drop the price by $15,000. We sat down, looked at the numbers, and proposed a $15,000 seller credit to fund a 2-1 temporary rate buydown instead. The seller accepted, my client saved double the monthly amount they would have saved with the price drop, and they kept their cash in the bank.

This is exactly the kind of market I enjoy coaching people through. No one is panicking anymore, we have the time to structure your loan correctly, and we can build a monthly payment on purpose instead of just accepting whatever rate sheet is handed to us. We are no longer writing blind offers on the back of napkins while waiving inspections. We can sit down, analyze the property, look at the program guidelines, and make a calculated financial move that protects your wealth.

How I'd handle it

If I were buying a home with my own money today, I would actively hunt for properties that have been on the market for more than twenty days and offer full list price paired with a request for maximum seller concessions. I would use that seller cash to buy down my rate permanently or fund a temporary buydown, ensuring my initial years of homeownership are incredibly affordable while keeping my liquid cash reserves entirely intact.

Talk it through with me

If you want to map out your own numbers and see how seller concessions can reshape your monthly payment, reach out to me directly to go over your scenario. We can complete a pre-approval in about five minutes and work toward our average closing time of 15 days or less so you are ready to negotiate with real leverage.

TopicsHome BuyingMortgage StrategySeller ConcessionsKing County Real Estate
All dom's take guides

Keep reading

Ready for a straight answer on your numbers?

A twenty-minute call gets you a real payment range, a cash-to-close figure, and a plan for what comes next.